web analytics

This past week I’ve been thinking about what it means to be “a writer” and the notion that there are “real” writers as opposed to . . . ?

Many of us call ourselves “writers.” In my case, writing takes up a huge chunk of the time I spend earning a living. Does that make me “a writer” or just a person whose professional endeavors require me to do a lot of writing? Is there a difference? If there is a difference, is it meaningful or of no import?

And what about folks who work at jobs where they do not spend a lot of time writing, but pursue writing projects in their free time whether it be drafting that novel they have always dreamed of seeing published, blogging, keeping a diary, composing poetry . . .

Am I any more a “writer” than those folks? Is it accurate to deem what I do “real” writing and use some other term — although I don’t know what it would be — to describe what they do?

Richard Bach, author of Jonathan Livingston Seagull, says that “A professional writer is an amateur who didn’t quit.”

Writing is such an intensely personal endeavor, even in the context of completing the most technically-oriented, impersonal composition. Writers talk about putting their blood, sweat and tears on the page and that occurs despite the genre. I can attest that there is more than a small piece of my soul revealed in many of the legal pleadings and briefs I have drafted over the years. So the style of writing and venue where it is published cannot serve, in my opinion, as the dispositive factors.

What about the idea of publication? Is that what sets “real” writing and writers apart? After all, we refer to writers as published in order to elevate and set them apart. But the concept of “publication,” in its purest form, is not limited to being on the best-seller lists. Publishing can be as simple as making a copy of your work and giving it to one person to review and critique. So I don’t think that’s the key, either.

When in doubt, consult the dictionary. The Random House Unabridged Dictionary actually lists seven definitions for the word “writer,” including “a person engaged in writing books, articles, stories, etc., esp. as an occupation or profession; an author or journalist.” However, this definition is also included: “A person who commits his or her thoughts, ideas, etc., to writing.” That’s a simple definition that can apply to myriad persons and scenarios.

You’ve heard it said, of course, that the destination is not what matters. The journey is of utmost importance. It seems to me that it is more important to focus on the purpose of the writing than the status of the writer or nature/style of the writing. Jay asked about translation which is a perfect example with which to consider my point. The purpose of translating a composition is to make it available to a wider audience. The goal is to be faithful to the original author’s words, meaning, and intent. To me, that type of “writing” is legitimate, worthy of respect and “real.”

But so is the individual who keeps a journal for the purpose of memorializing the events of his/her life, examining and understanding how they impact him/her, exploring his/her feelings about the things that happen to him/her. The diary may never been read by another person. Does that make the author’s endeavors any less “real” than the efforts of the writer whose work tops the New York Times bestseller list? Not for me.

Why? Because, as I observed above, the purpose of the writing is, for me, key. The written product that is never published, never shared is created by a “real” writer and is “real” writing if the act of writing has meaning, purpose and is enriching or satisfying to the writer. As with art, music or any other creative endeavor, I don’t believe that you can characterize only some forms and expressions as “real” and, concomitantly, discount or dismiss others. It is all part of a continuum, a sliding scale and flows from our desire to expand our thoughts, our perspectives, our sense of self-worth and well-being. If the methodology is writing, I believe that is as “real” as writing gets.

From my perspective, we are all “writers.”


  1. Loving Annie

    Huh ? I thought I commented yesterday, Janie, about the Sopranos…

    Can’t wait to watch it tonight ! Wish you were here to share some popcorn !

  2. If you write you are a writer.
    I decided a while ago after feeling like I needed a certain amount of recognition before I could be a real writer to declare myself one.
    I do it and I enjoy it and that’s that.

  3. Hi there What the BLOG!? member! I wanted to give you a quick update on What the BLOG!?

    We are now into our 4th round of the Ass Hat Awards! This week’s theme is Celebrity Ass Hats… check it out to get details and sign up if you want to play.

    Remember, participation in the Ass Hat Awards is not required to be a member of What the BLOG!?, but it sure is a lot of fun to play!

    So… if you are at all interested in participating in the Ass Hat Awards… you MUST sign up for our NotifyList to get Ass Hat Awards update reminders! This makes things convenient for you AND for us. You’ll find the NotifyList sign-up on the top right of our mainpage. Don’t fret… this is not spam. We are fellow bloggers and not trying to sell you anything. These are just emails that give you a reminder everytime the Ass Hat Awards & What the BLOG!? makes an update to the page.

    Otherwise how will you know when we have a NEW contest!?
    (Besides checking back here every two seconds, which is mildly inconvenient.)

    Okay, okay. We’re done bugging you now. 🙂

    – Jen, Tiffany, & Mikala
    (your friendly neighborhood What the BLOG!? moderators)

  4. Mimi Lenox

    I do not believe there are guidelines and rules to what constitutes a writer. I have been a “writer” since the age of seven.
    We all evolve into different stages of our writing and learn more each time we set pen to paper – published or not.

  5. I’ve been thinking of this same thing myself lately. After selling articles and having a blog I feel that I can finally say I’m a “writer” without being embarrassed or adding an explanation. Maybe. 🙂

Pin It